|
The government needs to continue efforts at recapitalization to
allow the banks
to fully reform
themselves |
|
lgeria’s
banking sector has long been problematic. Before the Currency and
Credit Act was passed in 1990, Algeria’s banks reflected both the
economic and political shortcomings inherent in the country’s
development strategy. Conceived as the financial instrument of the
centralized economy, Algerian banks were state-owned, free of
private sector and/or foreign competition and existed largely
without operational autonomy, their core task being to passively
administer credit to the country’s state-owned enterprises.
|
With
the severe oil-price slump and the prolonged recession, the sector
came under increasing pressure in the 1980s. Their continued support
for the country’s failing SOEs – often to the benefit of corrupt
political or military leaders – fundamentally undermined the banks’
financial credibility, racking up massive portfolios of bad loans. The
Bank of Algeria – the central bank and then a toothless regulator
under the thumb of the Ministry of Finance - proved unable to prevent
the worsening situation.
Real change came in 1990 with the money and credit law. This handed
the Bank of Algeria greater independence to oversee the sector’s
reform and subsequent regulation. The key objective was to restore the
banks’ finances, setting a capital adequacy ratio of 8%. As a result,
the sector experienced a large influx of liquidity in the 1990s as the
government implemented recapitalization and debt-takeover procedures
at enormous cost to the treasury, with the total cost between 1991 and
1999 estimated to represent 45% of GDP.
Structural reform followed in 1997 to dismantle the monopoly of the
public banks. The establishment of private domestic banks was
permitted while the capital of the state-owned banks was opened to
private minority participation. The sector was opened to the entry of
foreign banks and the Algiers Stock Exchange was established.
The result is that the face of the sector has changed quite
substantially. Private Algerian banks have proliferated while foreign
banks, such as Société Générale, Arab Banking Corporation, and Arab
Bank, have entered the market, offering more sophisticated products
and services.
Yet much
also remains the same.
Despite the rapid increase in private entrants into the sector, the
same six state-owned banks are still overwhelmingly dominant,
responsible for over 90% of total bank assets. And even though the
banks have been attempting to implement internal restructuring of
their operations, the IMF stated in late 2001 that profitability
remains low, efficiency is inadequate and solvency is uncertain. In
addition, cleaning up the banks’ balance sheets – a process started in
1990 – is yet to be completed, with estimates stating the overall cost
to the treasury will run to another 8% of GDP. Majority privatization
of the public banks has also yet to be authorized by the government,
reflecting what many believe to be the reluctance of political elites
with entrenched interests in state companies.
|
Number of banks in 1995:
Number of banks in 2002:
|
6
31 |
Still fighting the legacy of 30 years of socialism, the banking sector
has faced much bigger challenges than its Tunisian or Moroccan
counterparts in modernizing prudential rules and accounting standards,
while also resolving the issue of enormous portfolios of bad loans to
the country’s failing public sector.

WHAT’S COMING
Capital injections. The treasury will make
new efforts to stabilize the balance sheets of the state-owned banks
in 2002. The External Bank of Algeria will benefit from a capital
increase of $86 million, while Popular Credit of Algeria will receive
a $105 million increase. An additional $249 million is also to be
allocated for the recapitalization of the public banks in 2002,
according to the Minister of Finance, Mr. Mourad Medelci.
WHAT’S NOT
Privatization. Although most other sectors are
open, Algeria’s public banks are still not on the list.
The onus is therefore still on the government and the banks: complete
the restructuring of the banks’ balance sheets, improve bank
operational efficiency and reform the relationship between the banks
and SOEs.
At the
forefront of this process
are the state-owned banks themselves. Traditionally the most important
has been the National Bank of Algeria (Banque Nationale d'Algérie),
which since its creation served both the private and public sectors
and held the bulk of total bank deposits. It was the first bank to be
accredited with conformity to the new monetary and credit regulations
established by the Bank of Algeria in 1990 and has since focused on
modernizing its operations and introducing new banking technologies.
BNA has sought to emphasize its corporate activities, with a
particular interest in public firms in textiles, iron and steel
manufacturing and mechanical products. However, according to Mr.
Mourad Chikhi, the bank’s CEO, BNA’s key strategy has been to access
the new and growing private sector. Its 2001-2005 strategic plan calls
for enlarging the bank’s portfolio of private enterprises that are
producing added value. Since 1996 it has built its private sector
resources to $1.5 billion.
The Foreign Bank of Algeria (Banque Extérieure d'Algérie) is another
of the large state banks. Created as the bank of the hydrocarbons
sector and of firms involved in foreign trade in 1967, BEA has the
most international experience of all the state-owned banks in Algeria.

The bank’s General Director, Mr. Boualem Benaissa, argues that the
changes that took place in the 1990s transformed the way the bank
operates. “In 1998, BEA was given managerial autonomy via its
transformation to a shareholding company. Now we can operate according
to the laws of the market economy, especially in the area of
competition, prudential procedures and stabilizing our loan
portfolio.”
The bank’s direction in 2002, Mr. Benaissa says, will be to focus on
the areas that have traditionally been the weak links in Algeria. “The
main challenge facing BEA today,” he says, “is its transformation from
a cash desk to a bank – a client-based organization.”
Popular Credit of Algeria (Crédit Populaire d'Algérie), which
traditionally financed smaller sectors, makes up the triumvirate of
state banks created after independence. With 120 branches and 4,200
employees, it is Algeria’s third largest bank. According to the Bank
of Algeria, CPA has satisfied the capital adequacy ratio of 8%,
although Mr. Hashemi Meghaoui, who has been CEO since 1997, argues
that it is urgent that loans to liquidated or loss-making SOEs be
resolved by the government as quickly as possible. Mr. Meghaoui has
pushed the bank to engage the private sector, moving its business from
90% public sector several years ago to 55% today.
Mr. Meghaoui is also keen to open the capital of the bank by forming a
strategic partnership with a foreign investor. “We need a first-class
partner that will allow us to modernize. Going it alone will be too
difficult.” The bank has already invested $25 million in its
information technology system across its branch network.
Attempted
decentralization
in the 1980s led to the establishment of more specialized financial
institutions. The National Fund for Provident Savings (Caisse
Nationale d'Épargne et de Prévoyance) specialized in savings and
housing loans, while the Bank of Local Development (Banque de
Développement Local) was formed in 1985 to finance communal
development projects.
The Bank for Agriculture and Rural Development (Banque de
l'Agriculture et du Développement Rural) was established to provide
loans to the farming and food processing industries. Created in 1982,
BADR remains the bank most specialized in the agricultural sector,
although it is free to service all sectors of the economy. It is well
placed to do so. With 286 agencies and 31 branches (with a combined
workforce of just under 7,000), it has the largest and most widespread
network of any of the banks in Algeria. In order to exploit its
logistical and geographical strength, Mr. Farouk Bouyacoub, the bank’s
CEO since early 2000, established an internal committee to make an
assessment of the bank’s relative strengths and weaknesses, with the
objective of developing international levels of operations and
services within five years.
“We did it as an act of self-criticism,” says Mr. Bouyacoub, “to know
if we are capable of fulfilling our mission.” The biggest issue, he
says, is the environment the bank is working in. While BADR is the
only bank to have fully computerized its operations, the limited
Algerian telecommunications network has prevented the bank from
connecting all its agencies to a single network and fully
dematerializing its payment process.
|